Garmin S12 Vs Garmin S40 Comparison And Review 2021

The S40 was released as an intial mid level premium golf watch in 2020 and the S12 is an upgrade of the very popular S10 entry level watch. Both watches are competitive in the space and will suit different types of golfers.

The s40 is a mid level watch with a color touchscreen that was released in 2020 and has subsequently been upgraded by the s42, albeit at a higher price point, while being almost the exact same watch.

The S12 is a black and white golf gps watch that is not in color or a touchscreen but it is fast, responsive and reliable with an absolutely unbeatable battery life.

Garmin S12 Overview

The S12 does what it says on the tin. It has plenty of features for an entry level watch but not as many as the huge swathe of premium features you get with the S62.

It is a simple watch with a black and white interface, controlled by 4 buttons, 2 at either side of .9″ x .9″ display. It is extremly easy to set up and use so a good option for seniors or less tech savvy players.

The watch is also high pixel meaning it is easy to read in the sunlight.

Flicking through the watches features using the side buttons you will find distances to the front middle and back of the green, green view, distance to hazards etc and things like your digital scorecard.

You get 42,000 courses that load quickly when you arrive at the course you are playing and the watch is among the most accurate and fast in the market.

You get Autoshot with access to the free Garmin App which tracks your progress over time and is compatible with the CT10 sensors as well to take your game tracking to the next level.

The batter life is insane in the S12, it will last a whopping 20 hours in GPS mode or about 4 rounds, it will last almost forever in watch mode.

It looks quick compact and slick as a sports watch and it comes in white and black.

The price of $200 is a little bit high at the moment and we are hoping it drops a little bit as it as a fantastic entry level number.

Garmin S40 Overview

The S40 came along in 2020 and at the start we weren’t overly impressed with the watch as it was priced a little high at $300.

That price has come down now and what you are left with is an extremely slick looking color touchscreen watch and it comes in three colors, Black, Grey and white with gold trim.

The watch has a larger 1.2″ x 1.2″ face and it gives distances to the front, middle and back of the green.

It also has green view feature in which you can manually place the pin on the green.

You get the same fast and accurate performance with the S40 as you can expect with any of the newest Garmin golf watches.

It has 42,000 courses along with autoshot and direct access to the Free Garmin golf app to track your progress with the game of golf.

The S40 comes without a slope feature making it legal for tournaments unlike other premium Garmin watches which come with slope.

Quick change bands and downloadable interfaces make this watch one of the slickest on the market right now.

It has 10 hours battery life which is only going to guarantee you at least one full round in GPS mode.

The S12 and the S40 are both similarly priced making the decision of which one you want a matter of preference.

Do you want the simplicity and long battery life of the S12 or the slick design and epic touchscreen of the S40.

For us we find the features of the S40 to be slightly better value right now but if you could afford the S62 which is a little bit more expensive, we would recommend that you go with that.

Garmin S40 Golf GPS Watch

In 20 Words Or Less

The S40 is a mid range golf watch from esteemed brand, Garmin. It combines a color touchscreen with exquisite looks and plentiful features.

Garmin S12 Golf GPS Watch

In 20 Words Or Less

An entry level golf gps watch with unbeatable speed and accuracy. With a never ending battery life of 30 hours in Gps, this is the king of entry level watches.

Garmin S40 Golf GPS Watch – First Impressions

The Garmin S40 is a beautiful looking watch that sits excellently on the wrist, it is also packing a crystal clear colour touch screen and ample features.

The watch looks a lot less bulky than the S60 and it has changeable straps and downloadable interfaces to suit your mood or the occasion.

The watch comes in White, Grey and Black with downloadable interfaces and quick change bands which allows you to have a completely different looking watch to suit your clothing or any occasion.

Key Features:

As you would expect with any Garmin watch, the features, performance and responsiveness of the watch are second to none.

For a start, you get 42,000 courses around the world and they load faster than the competition.

You get the Free Garmin app as expected which can track your performance over time through autoshot which tracks your strokes on the watch.

If you buy the CT10 censors, also from Garmin, you can get a real idea of how your game is progressing and which areas are letting you down, to the exact club.

You get an automatic scorecard with auto hole progression and the watch will ask for your amount of putts when you finish each hole.

The colour touch screen gives distances to the front middle and back of the green, distances to lay ups and an impressive green view with manual pin positioning to suit the course on the day you are playing.

You can connect to watch to your phone via Bluetooth but where this watch comes into it’s own is in it’s appearance.

This is a slick looking watch and the screen is 1.2″ wide and high. Quick change bands and downloadable interfaces give a different look and fell depending on what you want on the day.

The battery life, unfortunately will only guarantee one round in GPS and is perhaps the biggest set back of the watch

For the current price of $200, this watch is very competitive in the market and certainly worth considering for most shoppers.

Garmin S12 Golf GPS Watch – First Impressions

The first thing to notice about the golf gps watch is that the watch is slim and sleek with black and white .9″ x .9″ screen.

The watch is easy to use with 4 buttons, 2 on either side and the watch comes with either white or black straps.

The features are stripped down on this so it is perfect for anyone who just wants fast and accurate distances to the front middle and back of the green, hazards and lay up options.

Key Features:

The watch comes with 42,000 courses worldwide and we have noticed that Garmin loads the courses much faster than most of the competition.

You get all the basic features of the Garmin watch without any of the extra bells and whistles which might be distracting, unneeded and even troublesome for some less tech savvy players.

You do get green view which allows you to attack the pin more aggressively, autoshot which tracks the distance you struck the ball and a digital scorecard which asks for the amount of putts you had before auto progressing to the next hole

There is no advanced fitness features and this could be used just for golf or perfectly in conjunction with a golf rangefinder as you navigate the course.

The watch can hook up to your phone via bluetooth and display calls and messages but one of the key selling points with this one is that the battery lasts 30 hours in GPS mode.

A very nice upgrade on the S10 with incredible performance and a competitive price tag.

Garmin S40 Golf GPS Watch – Selling Points

  • 42,000 Courses Worldwide that load fast
  • Excellent looking watch with variable customization available.
  • Distances F/M/B of Green, Hazards and lay up options.
  • Green View with manual pin positioning
  • Free Garmin Golf App
  • Bluetooth Connectivity
  • Add the CT10 features for more detailed performance tracking over time.

Garmin S12 Golf GPS Watch – Selling Points

  • Sharp Black & White Screen .9″ x .9″
  • 30 Hours Battery Life In GPS Mode
  • 42,000 Courses Load Automatically
  • Fast Loading And Accurate
  • Green View And Distances To Front Middle And Back Of The Green
  • Free Garmin App And CT10 Sensors Compatible
  • Bluetooth Connection To Your Phone

Who Are The Garmin S40 Watches For

The Garmin S40 is mid level watch that was released in 2020 and at the time, it was a little bit overpriced.

When the S42 came out as pretty much the same watch, the S40 has dropped to $200 and it is now a very strong canditate for a mid level watch.

For anyone looking for a very good quality, excellent value, exquisite looking color touchscreen watch, this is definitely worth a look.

For anyone interested in the best looking watch, this is also a runner.

If you need a watch without slope for tournaments, this is a quality watch to think about as well.

Garmin S40 Pros And Cons


  • 1.2″ x 1.2″ Color Touchscreen Watch
  • Fast & Responsive, Highly Accurate
  • One Of The Best Looking and Fitting Watches
  • Quality, Customizable Looks
  • Free Garmin App
  • Green View With Manual Pin Position
  • Add CT10 Sensors For Better Tracking
  • Auto Score Tracking
  • Step Counter And Fitness Features
  • Excellent Value


  • Battery Life Could Be Better
  • Gorilla Glass Not Included For Free
  • No Heart Rate Monitor
  • Lacking More Advanced Features

Overall Score: 94/100

Check Out More Reviews Here:


Who Are The Garmin S12 Watches For

The Garmin S12 is for anybody who wants the best entry level golf watch and perhaps anybody who doesn’t want to spend a fortune on their watch.

The watch has everything you need to lower your strokes on the course without packing in any unnessasary features that can distract you from your game. This will be perfect for senior players.

This is perfect for someone who just wants the basic features and accuracy without spending a fortune.

Garmin S12 Pros And Cons


  • .9″ x. .9″ Black And White, High Res screen
  • Distances And Length Of Any Hazards
  • Fast, Accurate And Effective
  • Easy To Navigate Interface
  • Free Connection To Excellent Garmin App
  • Incredible Battery Life


  • Perfect For Technophobes
  • Could Be Cheaper, Look Out For Future Deals

Overall Score: 95/100

Check Out More Reviews Here: