Callaway Rogue Vs Taylormade Sim Max Irons Comparison And Review
Callaway vs Taylormade is a battle between two of the leading producers of golf irons in the world, without doubt.
Both of these iron sets are built for distance and are both worthy of considering for high and mid handicappers looking to shave some strokes off the scores.
Callaway Rogue Irons Overview
The Rogue irons surfaced in 2018 and contain plenty of the features that exist in the very latest Callaway irons.
First thing to notice is how sturdy and strong these irons look, they scream ball speed with the ultra thin flash cup face and distance focused lofts.
Tungsten weighting keeps the COG low and the variable face thickness gives high launching shots and incredible forgiveness in a premium quality iron with a large sweet spot.
These are perfect for high to mid handicaps looking for distance and forgiveness or perhaps make the step up from a beginner set.
Taylormade Sim Max Irons Overview
Taylormade Sim Max added to the incredible success of the M series of irons from Taylormade.
The irons are also built for distance and are very hard to beat for mid to high handicappers.
We see technology like the speed bridge that gives stability to the club and the speed pocket compliments an ultra thin steel face for impressive distance.
Inverted cone tech gives forgiveness and deep undercut allows for high strikes consistently.
For us the Taylormade Sim irons are very hard to beat in terms of performance and distance.
Callaway Rogue Irons
Category – Game Improvement/Distance Irons
Taylormade Sim Max Irons
Category – Game Improvement Irons
Callaway Rogue – First Impressions
You can feel the power in these irons from the moment you pick them up. The clubs are solid, the lofts are strong and there is no question that these are built to make the ball fly.
What Callaway tried with the Rogue irons clearly worked as they have kept so many of their features in the new clubs and as soon as you get them on the course, you can see why.
The clubs are going to add distance to your game, especially if you are upgrading from a beginner set and it would not be uncommon for high handicappers to shave 5 or 6 shots of their round with these.
strong lofts with tungsten weighting gets a high and far flight while the flashcup face is built for speed and forgiveness.
Urethane microspheres absorb any unwanted vibrations and these are a really nice set of irons for any player.
Taylormade Sim Max – First Impressions
The first thing to notice about these Irons is the striking looks. The clubs have a cavity back design with more thickness towards the bottom of the design for more ball speed.
In the clubs we have a low Center of Gravity, a wide sole for a bigger sweet spot, forgiveness and echo camping technology for a nice sound even on Mishits.
The Speed Bridge, Speed Pocket and and ultra thin face all account for club head transferring into balls speed for maximum distance, accuracy and tons of forgiveness.
The Sim comes in a Sim format, Sim Max and the Sim Max Os.
The Sim are going to be excellent for mid handicappers. The sim max is more forgiving for high handicappers and the Sim Max Os is more offset for anybody how needs maximum forgiveness and also offset to correct any slicing.
The Sim Max Irons have recently been upgraded to the Sim2 family for 2021.
Callaway Rogue Irons – Selling Points
- Tungsten Weighting For Low COG
- 360 Flash Cup Face
- Strong Lofts For Distance
- Urethane Microspheres
- Perfect For High To Mid Handicaps
Sim Max – Selling Points
- Speed Bridge Technology
- Speed Pocket
- Echo Damping System
- Ultra Thin Face
- Progressive Inverted Cone Technology
Who Are The Rogue Irons For
Who They Are For
These are built for players looking for distance and forgiveness. Whether that is the High Handicapper looking to improve or a mid handicapper look for more from their irons.
Released in 2018, the irons can still compete with anything on the market right now.
Rogue Family Of Irons
The Rogue irons are complimented by the Rogue X irons which are geared more for the high handicapper looking for more forgiveness from their irons while being willing to sacrifice some of the feel.
Both very good options for beginners.
Distance: 96/100
Accuracy: 94/100
Forgiveness: 94/100
Feel And Control: 88/100
Overall Score: 94/100
Check Out More Reviews Here:
Who Are The Sim Max Irons For:
These Irons are going to be ideal for High and Mid Handicappers who want a perfect balance of distance and forgiveness.
The Family Of Irons
The Sim Max also comes in the following:
Sim which is going to be better for those looking for more distance and less forgiveness.
The Sim Max OS are going to be the most forgiving but be prepared to sacrifice a little bit of distance for the pleasure.
Distance: 98/100
Accuracy: 98/100
Forgiveness: 96/100
Feel And Control: 88/100
Overall Score: 97/100
Check Out More Reviews Here:

Aidan Lehane here, I’m a Mid-low handicap golfer who has made tremendous progress in breaking 90 in just over 1 year of playing golf seriously.
I get out to the course or range as often as possible and review all the equipment I’ve come across on this blog.